F10 N20 528i - Cylinder 2 gives +-5.0 roughness correction under acceleration (Stage 1 / MEVD17.2.4)

Post #1

va2lizadeh

Watchlisted

Azerbaijan
Joined
31.10.2026
Messages
3
Reactions
0
Location
Azerbaijan
Hey guys, how is it going?

Could you please spare a little time and check my ECU file? Honestly, I'm out of ideas and don't know where else to look for the issue. Let me explain quickly.

Car: BMW F10 (2015) 528i with the N20B20 engine. It has Stage 1, Pop & Bangs, and a cold thermostat mod.

The story: After driving for a long time, I decided to take a datalog just to check how the engine is doing. And what do I see when I open the log? Especially under acceleration/load, the roughness correction on Cylinder 2 shoots right up to ±5.00! It's driving me crazy.

I've already replaced and checked almost everything hardware-related:
  • Spark plugs: Swapped/replaced with brand new OEM ones.
  • Ignition coils: Brand new, replaced.
  • Fuel injectors: Tested, and Cylinder 2's injector was also replaced/tested.
  • Compression test: Done across all cylinders, values are healthy, solid, and completely balanced.

Since all hardware checks are out of the way, my suspicion falls entirely on the tune file. Could there be something wrong in the map? For example, per-cylinder ignition timing tables, torque monitoring, pop & bang timing retard tables, or injector scaling/duration maps?

I’ve attached the files here:
1. Tuned file: STAGE 1+POPS+CT_000...
2. Original read file: TC1797_MEVD1724-20...

To the tuners and brothers who know Bosch MEVD17.2.4 maps well—if you have some free time, could you take a look and see if there’s a bug or a bad parameter in this file messing with Cylinder 2?

Appreciate any help or advice in advance, cheers!
 

Attachments

5.00
1 Rating

Post #2

I checked both files carefully. Your ECU is actually MEVD17.2.9, not MEVD17.2.4.

The file named "Stage1 + Pops + Cold Thermostat" is basically an older stock calibration revision, not a real Stage 1 tune. The power maps and pops maps are still stock.
I recommend flashing the original file first, resetting the DME rough-running and crankshaft adaptations, and checking that injector 2 is coded correctly.
If the correction disappears with the stock file, the modified file was causing the issue. If it remains, the problem is most likely related to injector wiring or coding, the DME injector driver, intake valve deposits, or a mechanical issue under load.
I've prepared a clean Stage 1 based on your correct original software, along with a separate Stage 1 version with pops.

Test the clean Stage 1 first.
 

Attachments

  • BMW_F10_528i_N20B20O0_MEVD1729_00001BC91D9601_9VS9G40B_9G4LBCX7_STAGE1_POPS_CS_NOT_CORRECTED

Post #3

I checked both files carefully. Your ECU is actually MEVD17.2.9, not MEVD17.2.4.

The file named "Stage1 + Pops + Cold Thermostat" is basically an older stock calibration revision, not a real Stage 1 tune. The power maps and pops maps are still stock.
I recommend flashing the original file first, resetting the DME rough-running and crankshaft adaptations, and checking that injector 2 is coded correctly.
If the correction disappears with the stock file, the modified file was causing the issue. If it remains, the problem is most likely related to injector wiring or coding, the DME injector driver, intake valve deposits, or a mechanical issue under load.
I've prepared a clean Stage 1 based on your correct original software, along with a separate Stage 1 version with pops.

Test the clean Stage 1 first.
İstədiyin mətnin ingiliscə tərcüməsi:
Thank you very much for your help and for checking the file. To be honest, nobody else would bother to check a file this carefully. I really appreciate your effort and time, thanks a lot!
 
Activity
So far there's no one here